India, Maharashtra, vijay kumbhar, News, Governance, RTI, Transparency, Civic Issues, Real Estate: rose city
Showing posts with label rose city. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rose city. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 31, 2017

TRREPL Case; Classic example of Police Public Participation….

Case filed against Temple Rose Real Estate Pvt. Ltd ( TRREPL) plotting and investment fraud is classic example of Police Public participation (PPP) .And that is the reason why TRREPL director is behind bars and chances of getting  investors money back  have increased. Thanks to  Rajesh Puranik, Police inspector of Economic Offences Wing ( EoW) who under the guidance of Commissioner Rashmi Shukla and DCP Sudhir Hiremath not only had a proactive dialogue with TRREPL investors but also  invoked Maharashtra Protection of Interest of  Depositors  Act (MPID)  in this case. Under MPID competent  authorities can seize and sell accused persons properties .Even if accused have sold or transferred the property to third party , authorities can seize those also. In TRREPL case even though accused have transferred properties to third party authorities may seize those.


PI Rajesh Puranik with his team and Mubina Sanaula, Deepali Deshmukh , Rashmi Nehete,Prithviraj pardeshi,  and Pravin Jain in Mumbai at  Sajanani's residence
The MPID court yesterday extended TRREPL directors Devidas Sajnani’s police custody till 5th June. Other Directors of company are absconding and hearing on sajanani’s wife and Daughter’s interim bail application is also postponed till  5th June. The MPID Act, deals with a speedy remedy for recovery of payments in default and also provide remedy by criminal proceedings with stringent punishments and attachment of property. As per the Act, fraudulent default by a financial establishment attracts conviction for every person responsible for the management of the Establishment including the promoter, partner, director, manager or an employee.

A project Specific Discussion Forum for Flat – Plot buyers who want to discuss or ask questions without disclosing their identity

SUBSCRIBE NOW                                                                        ASK A QUESTION
Normally in plotting scams people don’t come forward to lodge a complaint because most of times  the agents involved in such scams are their own relatives or acquaintances .And hence investors don’t dare to file police complaints against their  own people. As well some times police also don’t take cognizance of such cases due to lack of sufficient proof. And that is the reason why PPP becomes more  important. Unless people help police in such matters they can not move forward.

PI Rajesh Puranik , accused Sajnani Showing land at Pingori

In TRREPL case the investors formed some teams to help police. A team of Mubina Sanaula, Deepali Deshmukh , Rashmi Nehete,Prithviraj pardeshi, Prathamesh Pore and Pravin Jain went all the way to Mumbai .In first round of visit they helped police to arrest Sajnani  under guidance of PI Rajesh Puranik  and in  second round they went to sajnani’s home to make panchnama of documents.Other team of  Rushikesh Chinchole, suvarna jagtap and Santosh Rahane along with police went to Pingori . Where Sajanani showed a peace of land that never belonged to him but had sold the plots under various schemes. Police made panchanama of Pingori land.

Devidas Sajnani showing his Flat in Mumbai


Helping police was not easy job for investors , because  TRREPL scam is organised crime also. Their stooges had already mixed up with genuine investors and misguiding them since long .They were also preventing them from filling complaint against TRREPL .Keeping all the activities  secret from stooges was really a tough job. Even then they managed it skilfully.

Team of TREPL investors Mubina Sanaula, Deepali Deshmukh , Rashmi Nehete,Prithviraj pardeshi,


In TRREPL there is team of 15 to 20 persons who  are involved in this entire scam as owners. TRREPL  directors have properties all over Maharashtra. If investors in TRREPL scam want their money back they have to keep the momentum going till the final outcome.

Pingori Land
Till date , under the MPID,  more than  200 cases of financial fraud have been registered , involving property worth Rs. 14.000 crore approximately .This number is very less if compared to unregistered cases. Unless investors dare to file complaint police can do nothing. Though number of investors helping police is very less compared to 5294 plots in Rose city scheme, They have shown the way. Now its up to other investors to come forward or not. Under MPID only the persons register the complaints may get it back.

Related Stories











Subscribe for Free

To receive free emails or free RSS feeds, please, subscribe to Vijay Kumbhar's Exclusive News & Analysis

RTI KATTA is a platform to empower oneself through discussions amongst each other to solve their problems by using Right to Information act, Every Sunday at Chittaranjan Watika, Model Colony,Shivaji nagar, Pune, between 9.30 to 10.30 A.M.

RTI Resource Person, RTI Columnist
Phone – 9923299199

                   http://surajya.org/
Email     – kvijay14@gmail.com
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/user/kvijay14

Monday, May 29, 2017

Devidas Sajnani behind the bars, other plotting and investment scammers stunned !

After economic offences wing ( EoW)  arrested Devidas Sajnani of Temple Rose Real Estate pvt ltd ( TRREPL) many other such scammers are stunned as and perhaps that was the first time any plotting scammer has been put behind the bars. Normally such scammers go scott free because of lack of complaints.After his arrest deceived investors are coming forward to lodge the complaints. However some people are still scared to come forward. And that is the reason why  such scammers dare to cheat people on regular basis. In TRREPL case though I wrote a blog, had a dialogue with investors, EoW also had a dialogue with them even then things were not moving forward due to lack of complainant. Earlier nobody was ready to lodge a complaint or share documents with police. However when one of the investors in Rose City scheme Mrs Nitin shukla Tiwari lodged a complaint entire scenario changed.



After Mrs Tiwari’s complaint EoW Police Inspector Rajesh Puranik arrested Sajnani and brought him to pune. Looking in to gravity of the case EoW is also seeking help of Enforcement Directorate (ED).Though TRREPL director Sajnani is arrested , There are hundreds of such companies involved in same kind of cheating. Some of such companies are established by former employees of TRREPL only. Their modus operandi is also same as TRREPL. If people dare many such scammers will follow the suit. Unless people come forward such scams will not stop. For those who want to discuss such sham projects without disclosing their names, a facility has been provided on http://vijaykumbhar.com/Discussion_Forum.aspx As far TRREPL is concerned they have spread their net throughout Maharashtra and outside. List of some of  their projects is reproduced below. Last number against each projects shows the number of plot either sold or are for sale.

A project Specific Discussion Forum for Flat – Plot buyers who want to discuss or ask questions without disclosing their identity

SUBSCRIBE NOW                                                                        ASK A QUESTION

N A Projects

1. ROSE MIDOWS  Phase I soagaon , shahapur Thane – 228 
Survey No Not given, Claim _ GIC  Housing Finance ltd,
2. ROSE MIDOWS Phase II soagaon , shahapur Thane  – 48
3. ROSE LAKE VIEW PHASE I – Ambivali Thane  - 226
4. ROSE LAKE VIEW PHASE II – Ambivali Thane  - 377
5. ROSE HILL VIEW , Chafel, patan, satara                         - 29
6. ROSE ANGAN Phase I , Paneri , Patan , Satara             - 79
7. ROSE PARADISE , Pimploli, Karjat, Raigad               -193
8. ROSE CLASSIQUE VIEW Hyderabad                          - 25
9. ROSE DREAM LAND Phase II  Vaishakhare,Murbad,Thane – 232
10. ROSE MOUNTAIN RANGE Phase I Parhe, Tal: Murbad, Dist: Thane – 367
11. ROSE MOUNTAIN RANGE Phase II Parhe,Murbad, Thane -445

TP Sanctioned Projects

1. Rose Mountain View Umroli, Murbad, Thane -75
2. Rose Dream Land Phase I, Vaishakhare, Murbad, Thane -155
3. Rose Dream Land Phase II, Vaishakhare, Murbad, Thane – 232
4. Rose Mountain Range Phase III ,Parhe, Murbad, Thane.209
5. ROSE PARADISE PHASE II , Pimploli Village near Bhakricha Pada, Neral (East), Karjat, Raigad – 91

Proposed N.A projects

1. ROSE GOLDEN CITY Phase I,Khor , Daund, Pune  - 562 (549)
2. ROSE CITY Phase I , Pingori, Purandar Pune   -929
3. ROSE CITY Phase II , Pingori, Purandar Pune   -781
4. ROSE CITY Phase III , Pingori, Purandar Pune   -413
5. ROSE CITY Phase IV , Pingori, Purandar Pune   -928
6. ROSE CITY Phase V , Pingori, Purandar Pune   -646
7. ROSE CITY Phase VI , Pingori, Purandar Pune   -318
8. ROSE CITY PhaseVI I , Pingori, Purandar Pune   -233
9. ROSE RIVERIA, Velhe, Pune – 339
10. ROSE SERENE CITY Phase I Temburle, Taluka: Shahpur, District: Thane- 158
11. ROSE SERENE  CITY Phase II Temburle, Taluka: Shahpur, District: Thane- 462
12. ROSE RAIGAD CITY PHASE I Walsure , Mahad , Raigad -1186
13. ROSE RAIGAD CITY PHASE I Walsure , Mahad , Raigad -3175
14. ROSE ROYALE PHASE I, Sayale, Murbad, Thane     -569
15. ROSE ROYALE PHASE  II, Sayale, Murbad, Thane     -320
16. ROSE ROYALE PHASE III, Sayale, Murbad, Thane      -    42
17. ROSE ROYALE (NEW PROJECT) Sayale Murabad, Thane – 116
18. ROSE GREENS , Mal, Murabad, Thane                                 - 467
19. ROSE CROWN, borgaon, Karjat, Raigad                              - 375
20. ROSE PARADISE PHASE III, Pimploli, Karjat, Raigad            -27


Farmland Projects

1. ROSE WONDERLAND, Kalambe, Taluka: Patan, Satara. -63
2. ROSE AANGAN Phase II, Paneri, patan Satara                  - 141
3. ROSE VISION  Kharkhel, Taluka: Baramati, District: Pune.- 401
4. ROSE HEIGHTS, Ekalgaon, Taluka: Velhe, District: Pune – 251
5. ROSE GARDEN,Pingori, Taluka:Purandhar, District: Pune.- 133
6. ROSE AGRO FARM is a project of TEMPLE ROSE FRESH PRODUCE PVT. LTD 
Pingori -                                                                                   - 96

Devidas sajanani is director in many companies. List of these companies and associate directors of sajanani  is reproduced here. Most of these companies are involved in so called real estate , chit fund or financial business. Some  of these companies have also borrowed huge amount from various banks or financial institutes. Though Sajnani’s daughter name does not appear in the list , she was former director of some of the companies.




























Related Stories





Subscribe for Free

To receive free emails or free RSS feeds, please, subscribe to Vijay Kumbhar's Exclusive News & Analysis

RTI KATTA is a platform to empower oneself through discussions amongst each other to solve their problems by using Right to Information act, Every Sunday at Chittaranjan Watika, Model Colony,Shivaji nagar, Pune, between 9.30 to 10.30 A.M.

RTI Resource Person, RTI Columnist
Phone – 9923299199

                   http://surajya.org/
Email     – kvijay14@gmail.com
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/user/kvijay14

Friday, February 10, 2017

Temple Rose Real Estate Scam is an Organised Crime...

Temple rose real estate scam is organised crime also. There is team of 15 to 20 persons who  are involved in this entire scam. You will find their names almost  in every temple rose project as a genuine buyer . But at the same time they are involved in land deals for same or other projects with temple rose directors in all over Maharashtra. They pretend themselves as genuine plot buyers to deceive other genuine investors  only.


Image Courtsey timesofindia

And that may be the reason when   temple rose real estate scam was exposed so many plot  buyers called this writer but very few turned up for the meeting held there after for any further action. This happened because genuine plot buyers are scared & scattered and   others  were just stooges of the company itself. Unless plot buyer get united, there is hardly any possibility of getting their money back or plot.


Fear of losing money already invested may be another reason that  duped  investors  don’t come forward to take action on such scammers.  One person wrote this writer after  he  read  post on Temple Rose city scam. He had  bought a plot in their Rose City PH-1, Pingori Project. He had already paid them EMIs for around 2 years and stopped paying since last 1.5yrs.When he visited their office in Pune they again convinced him but asked him to pay the remaining money after they get the NA. He eventually did nothing for 1.5 year. Now how can the plot that was not in possession of Temple Rose Real Estate (TRRE) and the plot Temple Rose Live Stock(TRLS)  has already sold can be NA? .

Another example is of rose city Phase VII .Actually Rose city phase I to VI were related to survey no 810 and phase VII was related to survey no 827.As per temple rose website there are still some plots available for sale. However they have already sold all that land . They had done same thing in case of rose city other phases.

Temple Rose have broke almost all laws , rules and regulation regarding land deals and income tax also. Off course they have done all these crimes hand with gloves of public authorities in Maharashtra. Needless to say they why such authorities would have done so. Under the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, no person can purchase agricultural land in Maharashtra if he is not a farmer. As well there is ceiling on holding agriculture land by a genuine farmer and ban on dividing agriculture lands. Almost in all the land deals TRRE has executed with registration department there nothing mentioned how money for particular deed was paid or received?

Agreements with  plot purchasers are not done properly also .Actually documents for real estate have to be registered at the department of registration. Notarised sale deeds doesn’t bear any value. However notarization was also not done properly. When asked everybody denied that  notarization was done before the notary. Attesting affidavits in the absence of its executants or deponents and authenticating instruments without verifying the identity of persons coming for attestation and the fact of execution is illegal. And stamp paper that documents are notarized on has  to in the name of either of the parties to the Deed , that has also been not followed by Temple Rose.

So called Transparency is another funny part of Temple rose real estate scam. They have displayed names of the plot holder on their website. There is  “ view detail” option to check details of that certain plot. But to view that option you need to have application number. However none of the lot holder this writer came across had such application number.


In the nutshell everybody involved in  the activities of Temple Rose Real Estate Scam has played a significant role in its crime and hence it falls in the category of organised crime . Criminal activities that are planned and controlled by powerful groups and carried out on a large scale Fall in that category.

Related Stories

Temple Rose Plotting Scam Exposed



Number of fools who want to get cheated is multi million times more than the actual cheaters in Ponzi Investment


Subscribe for Free

To receive free emails or free RSS feeds, please, subscribe to Vijay Kumbhar's Exclusive News & Analysis

RTI KATTA is a platform to empower oneself through discussions amongst each other to solve their problems by using Right to Information act, Every Sunday at Chittaranjan Watika, Model Colony,Shivaji nagar, Pune, between 9.30 to 10.30 A.M.

RTI Resource Person, RTI Columnist
Phone – 9923299199
Email – kvijay14@gmail.com
Website – http://surajya.org/
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/user/kvijay14